This is actually the best phone case I’ve ever used, and I’ve gone through dozens. The reason for the 3 start is not due to the working or quality of this case. My issue is it’s not very attractive when your wearing dress close or anything beyond blue jeans. A similar case in leather would be great, also if the belt clip was removal that would earn 10 stars. Belts are expensive and the clips on phone cases eat belts, I prefer the belt loop. I’ve never had a belt loop fail but I’ve has several belt clips fail resulting in the loss of a very expensive phone.